Your grandmother made the stuffing for as long as you can remember. This Thanksgiving, she sits at the head of the table and watches your cousin carry it in from the kitchen. She smiles at you, warm and polite, and asks your name.
You tell her. She pats your hand and says you seem like a nice young person. Then someone passes the rolls, and you spend the rest of dinner carrying a grief you can’t put a word to.
Family therapist Pauline Boss coined a term for it in the 1970s: ambiguous loss. In her book Loving Someone Who Has Dementia, she applies it to families like yours. After a death, Boss explains, you know the loss is real and you can grieve it. With dementia, you wait in a limbo with no end date. Neighbors don’t drop off casseroles for this kind of loss, and your family holds no service.
Two true sentences
Boss teaches what she calls both-and thinking, where you let two conflicting truths stand side by side. She gives one example a daughter might learn to think about her mother: “She’s here and she’s also gone. She knows me and she doesn’t know me.”
Both sentences can sit at the same Thanksgiving table. Your grandmother may forget your name and squeeze your hand when the pie comes out. You can miss her recipe and laugh with her at your uncle’s terrible jokes in the same hour. You don’t have to choose one feeling and set the other aside.
Setting the table for who they are now
November is National Alzheimer’s Disease Awareness Month, and you are far from alone at that table. The Alzheimer’s Association estimates that 7.4 million Americans aged 65 and older live with Alzheimer’s this year, and more than 12 million people care for them without pay. The Alzheimer’s Association shares holiday guidance for these families each year, and a few small changes can make the meal easier on her and on you.
Write to your relatives before they arrive. Tell them how she has changed, and remind them that Alzheimer’s causes those changes. Your aunt who hasn’t visited since spring will walk in prepared, and your grandmother won’t have to absorb her shock.
Plan the meal for midday. Some people living with dementia grow more confused or restless toward nightfall, a pattern called sundowning, so an afternoon dinner can spare her a hard night.
Give her a job she enjoys, like folding napkins or setting out the forks. Keep to one conversation at a time, since cross talk is hard to follow for a person living with dementia. If she calls you by your mother’s name, answer it. The Alzheimer’s Association advises families to skip the corrections and respond to her tone.
Let the music carry some of it
Many families find that a person living with Alzheimer’s can sing along to old songs after other memories fade. Researchers have found that the brain areas tied to long-known songs showed less damage than other regions in people living with Alzheimer’s. Your grandmother may lose the year she married and keep the carol she sang in church.
Put on the records she played when your parents were small. Sing along, and let her take the lead.
Care for the person carrying the most
If you care for a parent or partner living with Alzheimer’s through the rest of the year, the holidays add weight to a load you already carry. Statistics show that 59% of dementia caregivers describe their emotional stress as high or very high. You can scale back. Your sister can bake the pie this year and make it her tradition. Ask your brother to sit with Dad after dinner while you walk around the block.
The second verse
Later in the evening, someone turns up the music. Your grandmother doesn’t remember your name. She knows the second verse, though, and she sings it with you, and for a few minutes you hold both things at once.
Support for you and your family
For more ways to stay close to someone you love who is living with Alzheimer’s, read Flawless Founder Janine Francolini’s 10 Ways to Connect With Your Loved One Who Has Alzheimer’s, drawn from her visits with her own mother.
The Alzheimer’s Association runs a free 24/7 Helpline at 800-272-3900 for caregivers and families with any question. You can find their full list of holiday tips at alz.org/help-support/resources/holidays.
If you or someone you know needs to talk to someone right now, call, text, or chat 988 for a free, confidential conversation with a trained counselor, available 24/7.








